Deep Scaling and Transformative Knowledge Required to Expand Agroecology Across Food Systems

A critical barrier confronting the global transformation of food systems is that agroecology-based initiatives frequently remain confined to isolated, small-scale implementations that struggle to expand. In a scientific perspective published in Frontiers in Agronomy, researchers José Luis Vicente-Vicente, María D. López-Rodríguez, and Gadea Claver-Barrios examine why local agroecological solutions encounter systemic bottlenecks and fail to achieve widespread adoption. The authors argue that conventional efforts to replicate farming techniques or advance supportive public policies are insufficient without a foundational process known as deep-scaling. Grounded in transdisciplinary principles, deep-scaling centers on the generation of transformative knowledge, which redefines cultural roots, shared values, and power relations through dedicated agroecological Communities of Practice.

Agroecology has increasingly been put forward as a comprehensive pathway to transition from unsustainable corporate agri-food models toward regionalized food networks that are equitable, ecologically resilient, and sustainable. Across diverse global regions, communities have implemented practical alternatives spanning every node of the supply chain, including community-supported agriculture, seed banks, producer and consumer cooperatives, agroecological farmers markets, and participatory guarantee systems. Despite these real-world innovations, the authors observe that alternative projects regularly face structural resistance from the dominant industrial food system. Drawing on earlier analyses of institutional pushback, the researchers highlight how isolated initiatives often succumb to systemic rejection through an expulsion effect where projects collapse over time, an encapsulation effect where initiatives are restricted to marginal niches, or a conventionalization effect where projects gradually shed their alternative commitments.

To overcome these systemic vulnerabilities, the perspective evaluates agroecological expansion across three interrelated dimensions: scaling out through geographic and territorial replication, scaling up through institutional governance and supportive legislation, and deep-scaling through the co-production of transformative knowledge. While substantial historical momentum has been devoted to scaling out and scaling up initiatives—particularly within Latin America—the authors demonstrate that deep-scaling has received comparatively limited focus. They define transformative knowledge as critical, situated insight that actively investigates and questions systemic problems and dominant power hierarchies rather than settling for incremental technical adjustments. Consequently, deep-scaling provides the cultural and cognitive infrastructure required for agroecological practices to retain their original integrity as they grow.

The structural foundation of deep-scaling depends on creating agroecological Communities of Practice, which function as collaborative learning platforms uniting scientific researchers, farmers, technicians, and local citizens. These collaborative spaces operate along two core transdisciplinary tenets: social learning and knowledge co-production. Social learning serves as a communicative and relational process that fosters horizontal dialogue across three distinct evolutionary dimensions: an operational level focused on solving routine technical problems through single-loop learning, a strategic level that questions underlying assumptions to do different things via double-loop learning, and a transformative level that restructures shared values, collective worldviews, and mutual responsibilities. This progression enables a hybridized integration of academic and experiential insights, establishing equitable spaces for context-specific problem solving.

Examining empirical evidence across different world regions, the authors show that agroecological scaling has advanced unevenly across the globe. Latin America stands as a primary hotspot for scaling efforts, offering instructive operational models where grassroots organizations link educational spaces with field-level implementation. Prominent examples include Brazil’s Landless Workers Movement, which establishes popular peasant education based on constructivist, horizontal pedagogical models such as the peasant-to-peasant methodology and a respectful dialogue of knowledges that treats traditional and scientific expertise as epistemologically equal. In tandem with technical rural extension networks, these communities successfully pair territorial replication with deep-scaling, which is subsequently reinforced by institutional procurement programs that mandate dedicated public purchasing from small-scale agroecological growers.

Conversely, the authors observe that agroecological initiatives across Europe and other Global North contexts remain comparatively fragmented. While European jurisdictions have attempted scaling-up initiatives—such as creating urban food policy councils, local agroecology networks, and municipal governance policies—these regulatory instruments frequently lack the enabling conditions and grassroots momentum provided by deep-scaling. Even when legal land reforms are proposed to assist smallholders, their full implementation depends on cultivating shared societal perspectives that treat agricultural land as a collective common good. The researchers emphasize that without robust communities of practice cultivating deep-scaling from the bottom up, institutional policies and isolated demonstration projects struggle to effect long-term systemic change.

To systematically operationalize deep-scaling within broader transitions, the authors construct a sequential three-phase framework designed to guide research and practice. The first phase entails establishing long-term social learning and knowledge co-production processes within agroecological Communities of Practice to define the foundational transformative knowledge necessary for systemic transformation. In this opening stage, actors build relational trust, analyze food system vulnerabilities, and jointly determine common strategic goals. Because transformative social learning serves as the operational prerequisite for authentic co-production, this phase ensures that technical farming practices are firmly anchored in equitable collaboration and shared systemic priorities.

The second phase of the framework focuses on the rigorous monitoring and evaluation of co-produced knowledge to verify that practical solutions retain their transformative capacity and do not dilute into incremental adjustments. Within this phase, Communities of Practice utilize iterative co-learning cycles, such as living lab arrangements and citizen-science tracking protocols, to critically assess agricultural and distribution methods against operational, strategic, and transformative criteria. By systematically reviewing food flows and ecological outcomes against structured evaluative frameworks, participating actors can introduce evidence-based modifications in real time, confirming that local practices continue to challenge conventional system dynamics before attempting wider expansion.

The third phase of the sequence mobilizes the validated transformative knowledge to massify agroecology across broader regional and political landscapes. Once collaborative practices demonstrate tangible efficacy and achieve broad community consensus, initiatives can deliberately expand outward into new territories through scaling out and upward into institutional policy through scaling up. The perspective underscores that expanding into new regions invariably encounters novel soil characteristics, varying biophysical environments, and distinct cultural farming traditions, requiring an ongoing, adaptive dialogue rather than the rigid, top-down dissemination of pre-packaged solutions.

The authors illustrate their three-phase process through the case of agroecological lighthouses—specialized operational centers designed to implement innovative management practices and reconfigure local farming ecosystems. In Latin America, lighthouses commonly integrate popular education and farmer-to-farmer exchanges, naturally accomplishing the initial phases of deep-scaling. In contrast, a global systematic map highlighted in the paper revealed that of eleven studies assessing agroecological lighthouses for scaling, nine were situated in the Global South. While experimental and demonstration farms are widespread throughout the Global North, the authors point out that these facilities largely fail to function as true agroecological lighthouses because they have not developed genuine Communities of Practice capable of transdisciplinary co-production.

Concurring with their diagnostic model, the perspective outlines critical priorities for future agroecological research and policy. The authors conclude that sustainable massification cannot succeed without prior deep-scaling grounded in continuous non-academic collaboration. They call for creating globally coordinated, publicly accessible inventories and repositories to catalog verified agroecological experiences while protecting community contributions and contextual metadata. Ultimately, the authors urge future scientific investigations to concentrate on developing standardized evaluative methodologies capable of tracking whether co-produced knowledge effectively progresses from basic operational fixes to profound, system-wide transformations.

To further contextualize the mechanics of transformation within agri-food networks, the perspective links agroecological principles directly to systemic restructuring. Genuine transformation requires re-designing agroecosystems to harness natural cycles, biological diversification, and ecological synergies, while simultaneously re-connecting producers and consumers across local territories. The researchers stress that this operational shift must be accompanied by changes in diets, resource governance, social fairness, and broader public participation. Within this multifaceted transition, knowledge co-production acts as an essential accelerator, allowing diverse stakeholders to actively bridge agricultural production techniques with territorial governance.

A concrete operationalization of this approach is illustrated through living lab models established in regional food hubs. In one highlighted case, researchers monitored the origin and volume of food flows moving through an agroecological hub using citizen-science data collection methods. By applying the Transformative Potential Framework to critically evaluate these empirical observations, the initiative generated evidence-based insights that were subsequently integrated into municipal territorial planning. This structured feedback loop demonstrated how systematic tracking allows communities to substantiate their local practices, refine distribution dynamics, and eventually translate grounded outcomes into formal municipal frameworks.

Building on these observed mechanisms, the authors identify several targeted priorities for future scientific research on deep-scaling. They urge investigators to examine the exact relational dynamics and social learning processes operating within successful initiatives, which could uncover reproducible methodologies for establishing agroecological Communities of Practice across diverse cultural settings. Additionally, they advocate designing tailored monitoring protocols agreed upon by all participating actors, ensuring communities can determine whether local knowledge generation remains confined to technical problem-solving or actively reaches transformative thresholds.

Subject of Research: A perspective proposing a sequential framework for scaling agroecology through transformative knowledge co-production in communities of practice

Article Title: Transformative knowledge as a prerequisite for scaling agroecology

Article References: Vicente-Vicente, J. L., López-Rodríguez, M. D., & Claver-Barrios, G. (2026). Transformative knowledge as a prerequisite for scaling agroecology. Frontiers in Agronomy, 8, 1856610. https://doi.org/10.3389/fagro.2026.1856610

Image Credits: AI Generated

DOI: 10.3389/fagro.2026.1856610

Keywords: agroecology, deep-scaling, transformative knowledge, communities of practice, food systems transformation, social learning, knowledge co-production, scaling out, scaling up, massification of agroecology, transdisciplinary research, peasant education, participatory extension, agroecological lighthouses, living labs, agricultural governance

Tags:

 

Share Story:

Facebook
X
LinkedIn